Moore's characters, a bum who is known as the Emperor of San Francisco, and a young aspiring writer named C. Thomas Flood are discussing the well-dressed business folk that are scurrying about. The Emperor calls them "Fallen Gods" because the things that have made them successful are going away and they will soon be losing out to the "chinless techno-children... and their silicon-chip reality." Then the Emperor says something that really got me thinking. "Uncreative thinking is done better by machines."
Now, skip ahead 14 years and the chinless techno-children are now seen as the new Gods. The old Gods and their ability to push paper around has been replaced by the new Gods' ability to push large amounts of data around. The new Gods' success has simply been to find a more efficient way of pushing information (a.k.a. 'paper', 'emails', 'databases', etc.) around. But, has the increase in efficiency helped make either man or machine more creative thinkers? Or, have we created a situation where we're still on an uncreative path, but making up for it in volume?
When we look at technology in the legal setting, whether it is legal research, knowledge management, or electronic discovery, we've seemed to have taken the last 14 years to increase the scale of what we do. We can now push more information around -- We can now store Terabytes of information -- We can now virtually capture every keystroke that an attorney makes. But, have we made ourselves more creative, or have we simply increased the volume of information each of us can access? Uncreative thinking is still done better by machines. What we really need to ask is whether we are using the efficiency of the uncreative machines to push these tasks off of our people and allowing them to use their creativity to come up with better and more effective solutions?
Thanks to a book about vampires, I was reminded that machines (computers, software, databases, etc.) are efficient yet still uncreative in handling information and should be designed to our human resources to be more effective and creative in accomplishing their work. So, when you're ready to upgrade that hardware or software, you really should sit down and ask yourself this: "How does this make my people more creative and effective?"