5/18/09

Wolfram Alpha is a Great Resource -- But Not Ready For Legal Research

I'm one of the uber-geeks that rushed home on Friday and opened my browser at 7:00 PM to watch (yes, watch via video feed) the launch of WolframAlpha. The launch wasn't without its hick-ups (ran about 25 minutes late getting the video feed to work, then about an hour or so before the first bits of the website was ready for searches to begin.) But, that was to be expected.
Even the errors of having too many users hitting the database at one time was okay with me, and it was made kind of funny by the 2001-esque HAL to Dave error message.
I'm not going to go into a big review of WolframAlpha (if you're interested, here's a good one from SearchEngineLand). I will say this, though -- It is a great "data compilation" resource. That means that it is not Google, nor any of the traditional search engines that you've used since 1994. WolframAlpha compiles data in a way that presents a result. So, if I wanted to know the average temperature of Houston, TX in July, then this is my resource.
For Legal Research, however, WolframAlpha just isn't ready for that.
Here's some examples of "legal" questions that I asked WolframAlpha:
All of these came back with no answers. [NOTE: There are some additional examples of legal searches on Legal Informatics Blog as well.]
In fairness, WolframAlpha is in its infancy and isn't claiming to be a legal research tool at all. No one should expect it to answer all of these questions right out of the box, but I'm hoping that it can develop and expand its data collection abilities to begin answering some of these types of questions. To me, the "patents" question seems like something that can be integrated into the WolframAlpha database without much difficulty.
I'm happy that Stephen Wolfram has found a way to take his mathematical concepts and genius and figure out a way to pull different types of data together an produce a rational result. It is my hope that he can expand the WolframAlpha idea to expand into additional topics outside the hard sciences. I'm looking forward to the day that HAL comes back and says "Yes Greg, I can answer your patent question."

Bookmark and Share

2 comments:

Toby Brown said...

I patiently waited until Sunday to play with WolframAlpha - but came up with much the same results. I too was able to find out what the weather was like on a given day - but my legal market searches all came up: "Wolfram|Alpha isn't sure what to do with your input."

Still - it's a very cool tool.

Nick Holmes said...

The answer to all your questions is 42
http://www70.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=life+universe+everything

 

© 2014, All Rights Reserved.